At the Roundtable with USDA’s John Rich on October 15, 2026, at Holy Trinity Monastery in Jordanville speakers discussed New York energy policies and their effects on neighboring landowners. Emily Murray described the effects experienced at her residence following the commencement of operations at the Baron Winds II Wind Turbine Project in Fremont, New York. In short, since the start of operations her home has become uninhabitable. It is a moving and troubling story that I believe deserves to be resolved.
This post argues that New York should establish enforceable wind-turbine noise standards explicitly extending down to 0.5 Hz, supported by independent monitoring and a complaint process that investigates what residents actually report. That does not mean declaring that every measurable pressure fluctuation is dangerous. It means developing scientifically justified exposure limits and requiring measurements capable of determining whether those limits are met.
Fremont Case Study
An October 10, 2026 submission (“Fremont Case Study”) concerning Baron Winds Phase II in the Town of Fremont illustrates why this is necessary. Emily Murray describes recurring symptoms, her household’s departure from its home on January 21, 2026, and months of independent monitoring. Her accompanying letter asks the Department of Public Service to investigate whether post-construction testing adequately evaluated pressure fluctuations below 10 Hz and compared the measurements with individual turbine operating records and meteorological conditions. As of her submission, she reported that the household remained displaced.
Her report does not establish that turbine-generated infrasound caused the reported symptoms. It does, however, raise a legitimate regulatory question: does passing the required noise-compliance test necessarily answer the complaint being investigated?
In my opinion, New York needs to distinguish those two questions—and stop treating a limited compliance test as a substitute for a comprehensive investigation.
What the Fremont Report Describes
Murray’s report, The Fremont Project: A Case Study of Residential Low-Frequency Sound, Reported Impacts, and Displacement at Jobs Corners, is a resident’s investigation, not an independent regulatory determination. Although she serves as Fremont Town Supervisor, she explicitly submitted the report in her personal capacity.
According to her account, the changes at her residence followed the start of Baron Winds II operations in late 2025. She describes ear pressure, ringing, sleep disruption, and other symptoms, with conditions varying during visits, changes in weather, and apparent changes in turbine operation. She also reports that the basement was more tolerable than the upper floors. Her household ultimately relocated on January 21, 2026.
One of the most important issues concerns the scope of post-construction monitoring. Murray reports that she was told the microphone used during the consultant’s investigation had a lower frequency limit of approximately 10 Hz. She questions whether the investigation adequately characterized conditions below that frequency. That account needs to be checked against the actual instrument specifications, system configuration, calibration, filters, and original recordings—not simply accepted or dismissed.
She subsequently installed two Raspberry Boom microbarometers in different rooms. Her report presents pressure recordings examined with selected filters of 0.1–0.8 Hz and 0.7–2.0 Hz. These frequency ranges extend well below the lowest band explicitly addressed by New York’s current major-facility wind-noise design requirements.
The appropriate response is an independent investigation that can determine what the instruments recorded, identify the sources, and evaluate the significance of the results.
New York Already Recognizes That dBA Is Not Enough
It would be inaccurate to say that New York regulates wind-turbine noise solely through an overall A-weighted sound level.
The current major renewable-facility siting rules include a 45 dBA eight-hour limit outside existing nonparticipating residences. They also specify a 65 dB one-hour limit in each of the full-octave bands centered at 16, 31.5, and 63 Hz, together with a separate provision addressing perceptible vibration inside nonparticipating residences. The rules’ infrasound evaluation provision addresses the 16 Hz full-octave band and allows modeling or extrapolated sound-pressure data down to that band.
That framework acknowledges an important principle: an overall dBA value does not answer every low-frequency noise question. A full-octave band centered at 16 Hz does not characterize the much lower frequencies highlighted in Murray’s report. Nor does a structural-vibration requirement substitute for measuring airborne pressure fluctuations; they are different physical quantities.
Baron Winds was approved under Article 10, so its actual compliance obligations must be determined from its certificate, applicable local requirements, and approved testing protocols. The current statewide siting rules are relevant here as a policy comparison, not as proof of the requirements governing this particular project. Murray’s report itself identifies the Article 10 certificate and Fremont’s local law as necessary parts of that review.
The policy question is straightforward: should New York’s explicit frequency-specific requirements stop so far above the range residents are asking the state to investigate?
Other Jurisdictions Provide Precedents—but Not a Ready-Made Answer
Other jurisdictions have adopted low-frequency noise requirements or published infrasound assessment criteria. If New York is to claim that environmental regulations protect New Yorkers should consider what these jurisdictions have considered and whether New York should incorporate similar protections.
| Jurisdiction or source | Criterion | What it establishes |
| Denmark: wind-turbine regulation | A mandatory calculated indoor low-frequency limit of 20 dB(A), covering 10–160 Hz, at wind speeds of both 6 and 8 m/s. The assessment includes the combined contribution from turbines in the area. | A precedent for a separate, enforceable indoor low-frequency turbine-noise requirement—not a comprehensive standard extending down to 0.5 Hz. |
| Denmark: general environmental guidance | A recommended indoor infrasound level of 85 dB(G) in dwellings, classrooms, offices, and similar sensitive rooms, assessed over 10 minutes in the most exposed occupied room. | A dedicated infrasound assessment criterion, distinct from the mandatory turbine-specific low-frequency requirement. |
| Queensland, Australia: environmental noise guidance described in a technical review | An indoor infrasound criterion of 85 dB(G) for dwellings, classrooms, and offices, associated with guidance for industrial, commercial, and mining noise. | Another jurisdictional precedent for assessing infrasound separately; it should not be represented as a verified current wind-turbine-specific permit limit. |
| A 2025 peer-reviewed review and proposal | Proposed outdoor wind-turbine infrasound criteria of 90 dB(G) for daytime and 85 dB(G) for nighttime short-term assessments, with corresponding long-term indices. | A research proposal for exposure assessment, not an adopted regulation. |
Denmark is particularly instructive because its environmental agency explains why it added a separate low-frequency requirement. The agency had previously considered ordinary turbine-noise limits sufficient, but municipalities, industry, and residents requested specific low-frequency rules. Further analysis found that some turbine types could face difficulty meeting the new requirement in particular situations. The separate limit became applicable to turbines registered after January 1, 2012.
That is a useful regulatory lesson: a government can refine its standards without first claiming that all existing turbines are harmful.
At the same time, Denmark’s position should be represented fairly. Its environmental agency states that the infrasound emitted by the turbines it describes is below the hearing threshold and does not pose a health problem. The 2025 review similarly concludes that measured wind-farm infrasound is generally well below the hearing threshold and that infrasound which cannot be heard or felt does not produce the adverse effects under discussion. Those conclusions do not establish that Murray’s symptoms were caused by infrasound. They also do not establish what occurred at her residence.
The justification for further investigation is therefore not that the scientific literature has already proved her explanation. It is that the reported conditions deserve a technically adequate, site-specific response.
Why I Recommend Extending the Standards to 0.5 Hz
The proposed 0.5 Hz lower boundary is a policy recommendation, not a demonstrated biological threshold. A frequency of 0.5 Hz means one pressure cycle every two seconds. It falls within the very-low-frequency region examined in Murray’s report and would bring a substantial part of the currently disputed range into an explicit regulatory framework. Her report also includes observations below 0.5 Hz, so that boundary should not prohibit broader diagnostic measurements when warranted.
There are two separate tasks.
First, New York should require reliable monitoring and reporting down to at least 0.5 Hz. Without those measurements, an investigation cannot resolve allegations about that frequency range.
Second, the state should develop enforceable, frequency-specific exposure limits through an open technical process. Those limits should account for the available evidence on perception, annoyance, health, background conditions, measurement uncertainty, and source attribution.
These tasks should proceed together, but they are not interchangeable. An instrument’s ability to detect a pressure fluctuation does not establish that the fluctuation is harmful. Conversely, the absence of an existing numerical limit does not make a resident’s complaint scientifically unworthy of investigation.
I am not proposing that New York simply extend its existing 65 dB octave-band limit downward, or copy Denmark’s 85 dB(G) recommendation and declare the problem solved. Different frequency bands and weighting methods represent different quantities. A defensible standard must explain what is limited, where it is measured, over what period, and how the project’s contribution is separated from other sources. Denmark’s own framework distinguishes its G-weighted infrasound criterion from its A-weighted 10–160 Hz low-frequency criterion.
The Resident’s Measurements Are a Starting Point That Deserves a Substantive Response
Murray’s report contains several qualifications that should be carried forward rather than lost in the controversy.
She acknowledges that microbarometers do not independently identify the source of pressure fluctuations. Weather, wind, ventilation, doors, appliances, and other sources can affect the recordings. She also notes that the selected filters change the displayed amplitudes, so values from different filter ranges should not be treated as directly equivalent.
One example is particularly important: she describes substantial pressure variation during heavy wind when turbines were observed to be stopped and comparable symptoms were absent. That observation argues against interpreting pressure amplitude alone as a measure of turbine impact or symptom severity.
Similarly, two instruments recording comparable waveforms in separate rooms may help establish that a common pressure event was recorded, but it does not identify the turbines as its source. Her table associating displayed pressure amplitudes with reported symptoms should not be converted into a regulatory exposure-response relationship.
These limitations do not make the report useless. They identify exactly what a professional investigation must resolve.
What New York Should Require
New York already regulates part of the infrasonic range. The noise limits for wind facilities included in the ORES uniform conditions impose a 65 dB Leq, one-hour limit in each full-octave band centered at 16, 31.5, and 63 Hz outside qualifying nonparticipating residences. The issue raised here is not the absence of any infrasound regulation, but whether the existing frequency coverage and complaint-investigation procedures are adequate. The Fremont Case Study presents observations and monitoring in frequency ranges far below the 16 Hz band, without establishing their source or demonstrating a causal relationship with the reported symptoms. I recommend a state program with the following elements.
Independent investigation at Fremont
DPS should arrange an independent technical review of the resident’s recordings, the consultant’s original data, the instrument configurations, and the applicable permit conditions. Murray’s cover letter specifically requests technical review and a written explanation of whether DPS intends to undertake it.
The state should publish a substantive response identifying what has been established, what remains uncertain, and what additional testing is necessary.
Measurements matched to the complaint
Testing should include simultaneous indoor and outdoor measurements with a documented, calibrated response extending to at least 0.5 Hz. Investigators should retain raw pressure records and report frequency-specific results, rather than relying on a single overall dBA number.
The protocol should explicitly address instrument self-noise, wind contamination, building-pressure effects, and other local sources. Measurements below 0.5 Hz should remain available for diagnostic purposes when the circumstances justify them.
Controlled operating comparisons
Where practicable, investigators should arrange repeated turbine-on and turbine-off comparisons under reasonably comparable weather conditions. They should synchronize the measurements with individual turbine rotor speed, power output, operating mode, and curtailment records.
Murray requests comparisons of this kind. Her present observations of turbine activity and regional weather information are useful leads, but they do not replace synchronized operating records and on-site meteorological measurements.
Enforceable standards and corrective action
New York should establish frequency-specific limits extending down to 0.5 Hz through a public rulemaking supported by an independent technical review. The process should distinguish health-based limits from precautionary investigation or action levels and explain the evidence supporting each.
A standard also needs consequences. Permits should specify how verified exceedances will be corrected, how mitigation will be tested, and when operating restrictions are required. A complaint should not be considered resolved solely because one metric passed if the investigation has not addressed the conditions actually reported.
Conclusion
The Fremont Case Study is not proof that turbine-generated infrasound caused a household’s symptoms or departure from its home. It is a detailed resident account raising questions about measurement range, source identification, operating conditions, and the adequacy of the response. The Fremont Case Study and cover letter request independent investigation—not merely another statement that a project complied with selected sound limits.
Other jurisdictions show that separate low-frequency and infrasound criteria are neither an unprecedented idea nor inherently incompatible with wind development. But those precedents do not supply a ready-made, scientifically established 0.5 Hz limit for New York. Developing that framework would require additional work.
New York should do that work. It should require measurements down to at least 0.5 Hz, develop defensible enforceable limits across that range, and provide a transparent process for investigating complaints at existing projects.
A compliance test should answer a regulatory question. A complaint investigation should answer the resident’s question. When those questions differ, the state has a responsibility to address both.
