I maintain that there are two underlying issues with the Climate Action Council approach for the transition plan: the Draft Scoping Plan does not include a feasibility analysis and the Council has not developed an implementation plan. An implementation plan is needed to cost-effectively and efficiently implement the net-zero transition. Without these plans New York state is just crossing their fingers and hoping that everything will work out.
The ultimate problem for the future electric grid that is dependent upon wind and solar are weak when the load peaks in the winter because space heating is electrified. If an implementation plan was in place, it could encourage zero-emissions resources availability during future winter-time wind lulls, for example by discouraging utility-scale solar development where lake-effect snow is heavy.
An implementation plan could also reduce the chance that different projects could be working at cross purposes. For example, the implementation plan should discourage the loss of prime farmland because soil sequestration is needed to net out the 15% of emissions that cannot be reduced.
This page lists posts that describe projects that implement the Climate Act.
Climate Act Implementation Posts
- CLCPA Borrego Solar Rutland Center Solar 1 January 24, 2021
- Yet Another Industrial Solar Issue October 23, 2021
- Even More CLCPA Industrial Solar issues November 22, 2021
- CLCPA Implications of the Trelina Solar Project Approval December 2, 2021
- Climate Act Wood Burning Ban? January 26, 2022
- Status of Garnet Energy Center Application March 18, 2022
- New York 10GW Solar Roadmap’s Disconnect from Reality March 20, 2022
- Is New York State Coming After Our Furnaces? April 20, 2022
- New York State Electric School Buses May 5, 2022
- Capital Tonight Home Heating May 6, 2022
- Public Hearing on All-Electric Buildings May 19, 2022
- All Electric Building Act – Affordability May 22, 2022
- Hecate Energy Cider Solar Permit Approval July 27, 2022
- New York Siting Board Denies a Solar Project Application August 13, 2022
- Ithaca Public Housing Climate Act Investment August 15, 2022
- Working with Farmers to Ensure Climate Resiliency for the Future September 3, 2022
- Climate Action Council Question: Thruway EV Infrastructure October 10, 2022
- New York Siting Board Garnet Solar Project Application Decision October 28, 2022
- Clean Heat for All Challenge November 1, 2022
- New York City Large Multi-Family Residential Heat Pumps November 5, 2022
- New York Clean Energy Industry Report December 3, 2022
- Champlain Hudson Power Express Construction Begins December 5, 2022
- Syracuse Post Standard All-Electric Homes January 1, 2023
- New York Energy Storage Roadmap – Cost Projections January 8, 2023
- New York Energy Storage Roadmap – Cost Projections Part 2 January 13, 2023
- Initial Impression of New York Cap and Invest Program January 17, 2023
- New York Annual Climate Act Investment Requirements January 19, 2023
- Syracuse Post Standard All-Electric Homes Opinions January 20, 2023
- Solar Development Prime Farmland Scorecard January 21, 2023
- Guest Post: South Shore Long Island Whale Die Off January 29, 2023
- The Climate Act and Gas Stove Bans January 31, 2023
- New York State GHG Emissions Update February 9, 2023
- Guest Post – NYS Energy Storage February 11, 2023
- New York Annual Climate Act Cap and Invest Revenue Targets February 13, 2023
- New York Good Intentions Unsullied by Reality February 15, 2023
- Making Climate Policy Work, RGGI, and New York Cap and Invest February 17, 2023
- Here is What New York Climate Activists Want February 21, 2023
- Micron Electrical Needs and the Climate Act March 4, 2023
- Reliability is the Fatal Flaw of Net Zero April 2, 2023
- Climate Act Offshore Wind New Uncertainty May 10, 2023
- New York Sea-Level Rise Projection Methodology Update May 12, 2023
- Guest Post: More Hidden Costs – Gas Stove Replacements May 18, 2023
- NYISO Short-Term Assessment of Reliability July 2023 July 20, 2023
- New York Zero Emissions Proceeding Richard Ellenbogen Comments August 18, 2023
- Reliability vs. Advocacy Dogma – Climate Act Conundrum August 27, 2023
- Enough Land How will solar development affect upstate New York agriculture? November 2, 2023
- Upstate New York Smart Meters November 8, 2023
- New York Heat Pump Transition November 9, 2023
- City & State’s Clean Energy Summit November 20, 2023
- America’s Largest-Ever Investment in Renewable Energy November 22, 2023
- NY PSC “Gap” Reality Disconnect December 17, 2023
- Micron Rational Option not in the Final Scoping Plan December 22, 2023
- New York RGGI Operating Plan Amendment 2024 December 29, 2023
- NYISO DEFR Summary January 17, 2024
- Climate Act DEFR Cost Estimate January 18, 2024
- NYSERDA Solar Quiz Misinformation March 23, 2024
- Facebook Post that Gets It May 2, 2024
- Roger Pilke, Jr – Bullish on Solar May 14, 2024
- New York Assembly Cap and Dividend Naiveté May 17, 2024
- Grid Planning to Meet Climate Act Goals Summary May 18, 2024
- Solar Developer “Disinformation” Reality June 12, 2024
- New York State June 2024 Heat Wave Implications for the Grid June 23, 2024
- Madison County Wind Farm – Theory vs. Results June 24, 2024
- Filling the Gap in New York’s Decarbonization Plan: A New View of the Electric Grid July 5, 2024
- New York City Local Law 97 – Don’t Do It July 12, 2024
- Climate Act Presumption That DEFR is Unnecessary July 16, 2024
- Assemblyman Stirpe and the NY Heat Act July 27, 2024
- Offshore Wind Risks in the News July 30, 2024
- NYISO 2023-2042 System & Resource Outlook August 3, 2024
- Hochul Announces a Clean Energy Summit August 7, 2024
- NYISO System & Resource Outlook – Renewable Profiles and Variability August 9, 2024
- Future Role of Nuclear Power Worries Environmental Advocates August 18, 2024
- Pragmatic Recommendations for Climate Act Review August 19, 2024
- Renewable Generation Is Not Resilient August 23, 2024
- New York Future Energy Economy Summit Pre-Meeting Update September 2, 2024
- Offshore Wind Costs September 4, 2024
- New York Future Energy Economy Summit Post Meeting Preliminary Update September 5, 2024
- Has the Electricity Reality Check Arrived? September 7, 2024
- Climate Act Nuclear Reality and Clueless Anti-Nuclear Activists September 18, 2024
- The Math Does Not Support New York’s Climate Plan September 19, 2024
- NYISO Resource Outlook Dispatchable Emissions-Free Resource September 26, 2024
- Future Energy Summit Wrap Up September 29, 2024
- DPS Definitions for Establishment of a Renewable Energy Program November 6, 2024
- DPS Reviewing Progress Towards Achieving the 2040 Target November 8, 2024
- My Comments on Draft Blueprint for Consideration of Advanced Nuclear Technologies November 10, 2024
- My Comments on the NYPA Draft Strategic Renewables Plan November 30, 2024
- Keith Schue: Empire Report – New York Needs Nuclear December 5, 2024
- Last Minute Comments on the New York Energy Plan December 15, 2024
- New York Response to Part 490 Sea-Level Rise Amendment Comments January 3, 2025
- California Tipping Point January 9, 2025
- New York Cap-and-Invest Issues to Resolve in 2025 January 10, 2025
- Implications of the Moss Lake Battery Plant Fire January 17, 2025
- Comments on DPS Definitions for Establishment of a Renewable Energy Program January 24, 2025
- Madison County Wind Farm Retirement January 25, 2025
- Ellenbogen and Caiazza Comments on DPS Definitions February 5, 2025
- New York State 2024 GHG Emissions Inventory March 5, 2025
- Peer Review and Costs of Building Electrification for Commercial Users March 8, 2025
- Upstate New York Air Source Heat Pump Experience April 2, 2025
- Grifters Follow the Money April 8, 2025
- Energy Plan Board Meeting Misleading Information – Climate Change Impacts are Here April 10, 2025
- Complication for Assessment of Extreme Renewable Resource Lulls April 12, 2025
- Personal Comments on National Grid Long-Term Gas System Plan Report April 18, 2025
- Champlain Hudson Power Express Payment in Lieu of Taxes Grift May 23, 2025
- Status Update on New York Wind and Solar Generation Capacity Factors May 25, 2025
- New York Solar Siting Status May 30, 2025
- NYISO 2025 Power Trends Report June 4, 2025
- 2024 New York State Wind Resources June 10, 2025
- New York Cap and Invest Update June 13, 2025
- Higgins Comments on the NYPA 2025 Draft Strategic Renewable Energy Plan August 21, 2025
- New York Solar Siting Travesty October 17, 2025
- NYISO Short-Term Assessment of Reliability October 2025 – Overview October 25, 2025
- Differences Between Article 10 and ORES Shortchange Local Concerns October 27, 2025
- NYISO Short-Term Assessment of Reliability – Peaker Recommendations November 5, 2025
